Sunday, June 12, 2011

Thoughts on Women In Video Games

Surveys have shown that up to 40% of women in American play video games and 25% of the online gaming community is female. So why are women in video games still dressed like strippers, even when we’re the hero? I tweeted the short version of this question and got several fascinating responses. They went something like this:

You Feminists are too sensitive! Heaven forbid a female should be comfortable with her sexuality.

Of course I’ve heard things like this before. I’ve heard a lot of arguments defending the hyper-sexualized female video game characters. After all I worked at a video game store for 4 or 5 years and it was my favorite talking point. Sexism was just part of my day at this job. Not only was it hung up on the walls, but it was fairly common for a customer to ask for a male employee because he had a hard question. Often he was sent right back to me because I knew the answer.

In addition, we were regularly trained on how to sell to female customers (Quick! Take her to the WII section or she will be frightened!) and featured several Games For Girls sections. Usually these contained cooking games or games about ponies. I like ponies. I do. I also like Call of Duty.

But that is neither here nor there. The fact is that women are marginalized in all aspects of the video game industry, and I don’t get why. So let me take a moment to address some of the arguments I’ve heard. If I am missing some please let me know and I will amend the list.

1) That’s not true / I don’t know what you’re talking about

A few people have told me that, while there are some egregious examples, an actual pattern of hyper-sexualized-objectified female characters doesn’t exist.

To disprove this, let’s look at some random female characters from a random selection of games. To make it sporting I will only use images released for games coming out in 2012. I am certain, however, that you all know where this is going.

Batman Arkham City

Infamous 2

Pandora’s Tower

The Secret World

DOTA 2

Soul Caliber V

Dragon’s Crown (WHAT I DON’T EVEN)

I could not find any titles with a fully clothed female protagonist…or antagonist.

For History’s sake, let’s not forget our old friends Lara, Bayonetta, Nariko, Ivy Valentine, Mass Effect’s Jack and Miranda, Everything in Dead or Alive, Every female in Tekken…and Street FighterI’m sorry I can’t do this list…. It will take forever. I am sure this surprises no one. It’s a well-known pattern.

2) It doesn’t cause any harm

This argument assumes that alienating and objectifying an entire group of people is fine so long as it does not cause any harm. In the same way calling your mom a slut is not harmful because there is no measurable damage. Like racial slurs don’t do anything.

This is actually a false arguement. Even if it does not do actual physical harm it is an example of lazy writing/craft/artistry that brings the entire industry down. It’s cheap and needs to be called out simply because it’s tacky. Well done! You made Female Character A. She wears a bikini and talks tough and flirts with the main character. Or Female Character B who is shy and has to be saved from a tower-dragon-dungeon. We are all terribly impressed. Also bored.

The problem is not that I feel that I have to be a sex object because Lara is…though I’m sick of being asked to cosplay as her…. The problem is that, in video games, these sexy, big-busted women are what women ARE. Women are like chairs or guard dogs or Natzis. We are stock, nearly naked and in charge of our bodies only by revealing them.

The problem is not that women do not like the characters the gaming industry has created, but that they are not characters. Not real, round, unique, and complex characters like their male counterparts. Even if it doesn’t alienate and frustrate women and men alike, it’s sloppy.

Not to mention the fact that a problem doesn’t need to be fixed only if it is actively making someone bleed.

3) Majority Rules

This argument generally states that female gamers are a minority and the needs and wants of the majority should overrule that of the minority. After all, this is America.

There’s actually a bunch of things wrong with this argument.

While it is true that the majority rules in matters of voting another tenant of America is that the minority still have rights and privileges. They also get to speak out about perceived injustice and don’t have to shut up because someone points out there aren’t that many of them. That’s why the civil rights movement worked, and women’s suffrage. That’s why America is awesome. Also, while it makes sense, economically, to sell to the largest group, it is also ill-advised to alienate a portion of your audience – especially a growing portion.

What is implied by this argument is that all men want in games is sex appeal. This seems enormously unfair to all men everywhere. While I assume they exist, I’ve never met a man who purchased games for the boobies, not even the ass-holes who wanted to speak to my manager because I had one too man X chromosomes. Actually they usually wanted fighters.

It’s also wrong. If it were true Dead or Alive would be on top of the list of best selling 360 games instead of Call of Duty, Halo, Gears of War, Fable, etc. Why are these at the top? Because they are #$#!$ing solid, clean, well made games that know their genre. Their lack of breasts and thighs don’t seem to deter the apparently sexually insatiable gamers.

At the end of the day, game play is what is most important for everyone. For instance, even though it’s one of my examples, I am going to play Arkham City because the first one was a fluid, beautiful, action filled, joy-ride of extreme extremeness. Also Batman. Still, I will hurt a little inside every time Harley or Catwoman are on screen. Really? We had to make Harley sexier? She wore full-body spandex!

4) Men are objectified too

This argument is generally used to point out the trend of traditionally masculine, muscle-bound hero, which sets an unrealistic standard for men.

… like Mario.

Or Link, Ico, Megaman, Cloud Strife, Markus Fenix, Nathan Drake, Gordon Freeman

While the stereotypical male ideals of strength are important to some of these characters, few are concerned with sexual potency or women in general, (as opposed to females who are often defined by their sexuality). They are generally driven by such unbelievable concepts as doing the right thing. Their strength comes from their morality, intelligence, ingenuity, courage, etc etc. Even Master Chief’s strength came from discipline, training, and an awesome power suit. We never even got to see his actual physique.

In other words, they are actual, 3-dimensional characters. In this case it’s sort of a mixed message. If I may look backwards a moment to the “majority rules” argument, I suppose we are to believe that real life guys only want to see boobies and that game designers should appease them, while their in-game heroes are actually interested in complex problems in their world. Also truth and justice and stuff.

The fact is that it’s safe to bet that a girl in a video game fits one mold, while that is not true of male characters.

There’s also the fact that, by and large, men get to be clothed. Usually they are dressed in a way that makes some sort of sense for their job/adventure/role. Women, on the other hand, are generally in something revealing and un-safe, with all sorts of slits and openings to invite critical hits. I cannot conceive of a positive reason for this.

5) These women are actually in charge of their sexuality

While it is awesome to allow a character to draw strength from their sexuality, the derth of sexualized female characters suggests a belief that women can only draw strength from their sexuality.

Master Chief didn’t draw his strength from sexuality. He drew it from intelligence, strength, character and training. These made him a complex character. He didn’t also need to be sexy. Most female heroes are inherently sexy and then have other characteristics tacked on. Oh also she has a smart mouth. And likes shotguns…or whatever.

This seems to imply that sexuality is an innate quality of a woman, like noses or ears. These characters are not in control of her sexuality because they must either deny it completely or use it as a weapon. There is no middleground, unlike male characters who can even have sex in game (I’m looking at you Grand Theft Auto) and yet not be sexualized. Their physicality is only an element of their experience rather than a defining characteristic.

What I want to make clear is that mentioning a woman and sex in the same instance is not sexist. In fact, a complex, strong female character could have sex RIGHT THERE IN THE GAME and it doesn’t become magically sexist, or even objectify her.

The problem occurs with bad writing and character design, when her sex, her body, and her relations to the gaze of the viewer define the character. If the only way you can think to make a female character strong is to make her sexy and proud of it, you are a bad writer. Also an idiot.

6) Other people did it first

A lot of media sucks as far as sexism goes. Music, movies, and comic books all objectify women.

Well, if Sucker Punch jumps off a bridge are you going to do it too? Seriously, comparing yourself to other failures in civil rights doesn’t help your case.

Not to mention the fact that there are other things in these media. Even comic books, which have a terrible history of portraying women in Barbie doll proportions. The thing is, there are other genres under these larger umbrellas. There are huge portions of movies, music, and comics that avoid sexism completely!

That is not really the case with video games. If I want to play a first person shooter I will probably be playing a guy, or a girl in a tube top. If I want to play a fighting game…well I’m just screwed. The point is, if I want to play video games, I just have to digest this version of women. I can’t go to another artist or director.

7) There are some good girls!

I do have girl heroes! But I actually had to think really hard to come up with them, unlike male heroes, which took me all of half a second. I spent a lot of time growing up pretending that Link or Ash were girls regardless of the male pronouns. I am thrilled whenever a new rpg allows me to make a female character! Here are a few of my favorites:

Yuna is surprisingly one of my heroes. Although she is shy and soft spoken she is totally calling the shots in that party. This actually makes her even more complex. Even the main male character is just following her around. She is set up to sacrifice her life for the planet and she faces it with poise and courage, if a few tears.

Portal Girl is awesome. She escapes the grips of a torturous robot through her own ingenuity. Of course this is one of those cases where you are playing behind a disembodied gun, but still. It’s a she, and she rocks.

Faith: Mirror’s Edge. She was tough and capable in very unique and interesting ways, including the ability to jump between roofs and fistfight machine gun-toting baddies. She also wore clothes!

However, the fact that these examples exist does not negate the overall pattern of sexism within the industry. I don’t think it’s absurd to ask for good writing or to be acknowledged as a member of the gender stuffed in chain mail bikinis with our hips akimbo. I am a girl gamer, dammit, and there are more where I come from!

15 comments:

  1. 1. People sometimes hold BioWare up as a positive example here, and while I think they do a good job making strides to include LGBT characters who are also, y'know, characters, they don't really help with the costume thing. Well, not right now, anyway. Dragon Age: Origins was pretty great about it. Armor looked the same on women as it did on men, and some prominent leaders were women. With the sole exception of Morrigan (who was dressed like some kind of weird druidic stripper), everyone wore reasonable (if medieval) clothes and armor. The first Mass Effect was pretty good, too, at least about costumes. Let's not get into the entire concept of the asari (blue, all-female, omnisexual space-elves!).

    But both Mass Effect 2 (though a fantastic game) and Dragon Age II were huge steps backwards in that department.

    If you want to trace a similar degeneration, look at the way Jill changed between Resident Evil and Resident Evil 3. She went from a police officer in a beret with a t-shirt and pants to wearing a tube top and a miniskirt while shooting zombies. Because that's really popular, y'know, the tactical miniskirt.

    2. I'm glad you brought up Gordon Freeman. While some apologists for the current industry tend to focus on characters like Kratos and the Gears of War guys, the thing is they're made how they are to appeal to the player's masculinity, not to appeal to female players' sexuality.

    Gordon Freeman, though, is a nerd in a fancy suit. That's what he is. I think that's why Half-Life fans like him so much. And y'know what? Where are the female characters who get by on their wits and bravery? Don't point me to the half-dressed female magic-users in many JRPGs: they're only "smart" in game stats. I suppose there's always Samus Aran, but let's not forget that every Metroid game rewards the player for fast completion by showing you Samus in a bikini. Pretty obvious audience there.

    3. Portal Girl is named Chel and she is awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Okay, so. I'm going to begin this by getting hated: I'm usually the 'You Feminists Are Too Sensitive' guy. Which isn't to say that I'm a Chauvanist tool-bag... (although, I suppose I could be. Perhaps I'm not the best one to judge,) but I get a little desensitized to the claims of sexism in pop culture when I hear it every time somebody conforms to a traditional gender role. Just to let you know where my mind is usually. Direct hate mail accordingly.

    That being said, this article is FANTASTIC. I'm just re-entering the gaming world, and am getting irked at the two-dimensional female characters with overly three-dimentional chestal regions. I'm looking forward to the day when the whole porn-star inspired "she's EMPOWERED by the sexuality" argument dies in a fiery car crash. Oh really, being objectified into a fantasy object is an empowering experience? Especially when it's portrayed as the defining aspect of your personality? Huh. And the stigma against female gamers is beyond retarded, and should continue to be touted as such by intelligent people like yourself everywhere.

    Well done. Insightful, entertaining, well-argued piece. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bah! Blogger ate my comment from before. To summarize what I said but didn't get to share:

    1. Went looking for a sexy master chief a la Hark! A Vagrant's sexy batman, found only female versions of M.C. in skimpy armor (shock!)

    2. The Escapist has a series called Extra Credits, and one of their videos covers many of the points that you did and is also consistently good and insightful and amazing. Link for the interested: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/extra-credits

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with everything you said, but I think point 4 is not true in its entirety. It is true that most male characters are more dressed than their female counterparts, but when their clothes comes off, they all fit into a physical norm for male characters, ripped muscles, six pack abs, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wonderfully written. Sums up my feelings entirely on women in games. Just wanted to add my personal favorite female character, Alyx Vance from Half-Life 2. She's smart, strong, independent, beautiful without being half-naked, and you actually NEED her to complete the game! Many female characters in games tend to just follow the main character (usually male) around and cry for help (like in Resident Evil 4). Anyhoo, excellent article and I will be sharing it. Great to see stuff like this around on the internet rather than misogynistic rants =P

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well...

    Everyone have a right view in this topic.. The women are like to play games which match their activities in their actual life.I also love to play dress up games, cooking games, room decoration etc..
    Safe online games

    ReplyDelete
  7. I couldn't resist commenting. Well written!

    Also visit my blog post: hacking software

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you, I've just been looking for information approximately this topic for a while and yours is the greatest I have discovered till now. But, what concerning the conclusion? Are you positive in regards to the supply?

    my website - psn codes

    ReplyDelete
  9. When I initially commented I clicked the "Notify me when new comments are added" checkbox and
    now each time a comment is added I get several e-mails with the same comment.
    Is there any way you can remove me from that service?

    Bless you!

    Here is my weblog adfly bot

    ReplyDelete
  10. Very interesting details you have observed , appreciate it for posting .

    "The surest way to get rid of a bore is to lend money to him." by Paul Louis Courier.



    my page - Adf.ly

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative.
    I'm going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

    Also visit my web-site; psn card

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi there, this weekend is good for me, as this time i am reading this enormous informative post here at my residence.



    My webpage crack password

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text
    in your post seem to be running off the screen in Safari.

    I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post to let you
    know. The design look great though! Hope you get the
    issue solved soon. Thanks

    my homepage - aimbots

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I'll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
    I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I'm still new to the whole thing. Do you have any tips and hints for newbie blog writers? I'd
    certainly appreciate it.

    Also visit my web site :: earn cash for doing stuff you Normally do on the internet

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement
    account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you!
    By the way, how can we communicate?

    Here is my webpage: increase youtube views

    ReplyDelete